Some firms have already announced that they will require all analysts to use the GAAP EPS figures in reports and models, which will account for the options compensation costs. However, the basis is the bargain element plus the original cost to exercise the options. Publication B Internal Revenue Service: In general, the difference between the FMV of the shares at the time the option was exercised and the option price i. The employee may also be entitled to an offsetting deduction equal to 50 per cent of the amount of the employment benefit if certain conditions are met. The bargain element is not taxed as ordinary income in the exercise year. The chart below highlights this trend.
Taxation begins at the time of exercise. The bargain element of a non-qualified stock option is considered "compensation" and is taxed at ordinary income tax rates. For example, if an employee is granted shares of Stock A at an exercise price of $25, the market value of the stock at the time of exercise is $ The bargain element on the contract is ($50 to $25) x = $2,
Selling Regular Options
When stock is sold that was acquired from exercising regular stock options, there is a capital gain. The gain is the difference between the sale proceeds and the cost basis. To determine a basis, the cost of exercising the option is added to the bargain element already taxed as ordinary income. If the stock is sold more than one year after exercise, the gain will be taxed at more favorable long-term rates than a short-term gain occurring in one year or less.
When stock is sold that was acquired from exercising ISOs, the tax implications depend upon when the sale occurs. If the stock is sold more than one year after exercising the options and more than two years after the options were granted, there are special tax implications.
This qualified sale receives favorable long-term capital gain treatment on the difference between the sale proceeds and the cost for exercising the options. If both conditions are not met, the bargain element is added to ordinary income in the year of stock sale. That causes tax on the bargain element at a higher rate than long-term capital gain. If the stock is sold more than one year after option exercise but less than two years after option grant, the transaction is still a long-term capital gain.
However, the basis is the bargain element plus the original cost to exercise the options. As the listings above reveal, companies whose stocks had appreciated significantly during the time period received an above-average tax gain because the intrinsic value of the options at expiration was higher than expected in the original company estimates.
With this benefit erased, another fundamental investing metric will be shifting for many companies. What to Look for from Wall Street There is no real consensus on how the large brokerage firms will deal with the change once it has been proliferated to all public companies. Some firms have already announced that they will require all analysts to use the GAAP EPS figures in reports and models, which will account for the options compensation costs. Also, data firms have said that they will begin incorporating the options expense into their earnings and cash flow figures across the board.
Conclusion At their best, stock options still provide a way to align employee interests with those of upper management and the shareholders, as the reward grows in with the price of a company's stock. However, it is often far too easy for one or two executives to artificially inflate short-term earnings, either by pulling future earnings benefits into present earnings periods, or via flat-out manipulation. This transition period in the markets is a great chance to evaluate both company management and investor relations teams on things such as their frankness, their corporate governance philosophies and if they uphold shareholder values.
If we should trust the markets in any regard, we should rely on its ability to find creative ways to solve problems and digest changes in the marketplace. Options awards became more and more attractive and lucrative , because the loophole was just too big and tempting to ignore. Now that the loophole is closing, companies will have to find new ways to give employees incentives. Clarity in accounting and investor reporting will benefit us all, even if the short-term picture becomes fuzzy from time to time.
Stock Picking Strategies The debate about how to account for corporate stock options given to employees and executives has been argued in the media, company boardrooms and even in the U.
The key variables are: The risk-free rate of return usually a three- or six-month t-bill rate will be used here. Expected dividend rate for the security company.
Implied or expected volatility in the underlying security during the option term. Exercise price of the option. Expected term or duration of the option. Reuters Fundamentals The slope of the graph is exaggerated because of depressed earnings during the bear market of and , but the trend is still undeniable, not to mention dramatic. Credit Suisse First Boston: Building a New Consensus: As with the industries above, individual stock results will be highly skewed, as can be shown in the following examples: Although the employment benefit is afforded the same tax treatment as a capital gain, it is not actually a capital gain.
If you are considering establishing a stock option plan in the coming months, contact your Collins Barrow advisor for more information and guidance. Information is current to October 23, The information contained in this release is of a general nature and is not intended to address the circumstances of any particular individual or entity. Although we endeavour to provide accurate and timely information, there can be no guarantee that such information is accurate as of the date it is received or that it will continue to be accurate in the future.
No one should act upon such information without appropriate professional advice after a thorough examination of the particular situation. As outlined in the March Tax Alert, the Budget includes a measure designed to slow the accumulation of passive investments within active corporations.
This measure is based on a calculation that considers both the amount and the type of investment income earned in a corporation. Understanding this calculation will guide an investor in developing a tax-efficient investment strategy going forward. Or select National for a comprehensive, coast-to-coast perspective.
Save the exploring for your next adventure
Consider the following statistic: Grants of stock options given out by S&P firms fell from billion in to only 4 billion in , a decrease of more than 40% . There are three kinds of taxes you should consider when you exercise your Incentive Stock Options (the most common form of employee options): alternative minimum tax (AMT), ordinary income tax and the much lower long-term capital gains tax. If your year-to-date earned income is not already in excess of the benefit base than when you exercise nonqualified stock options, you will pay a total of % on gain amounts up until your earned income reaches the benefit base than % on earnings over the benefit base.